All you need to change is 2 lines in the livery.
This is the Bazillian Navy one, which is non shiny:-
<sim>
<model>
<livery>
<name type="string">Brazil Navy, BMC</name>
<texture>Liveries/braznavy.png</texture>
</livery>
<bo105>
<hdr>false</hdr> <----- THIS IS TURE FOR SHINY
<als>true</als> <----- THIS IS TRUE FOR NON SHINY ( as it is on this one )
</bo105>
</model>
<rendering>
<refl_correction type="string">-0.42</refl_correction>
<fresnel-factor>0.2</fresnel-factor>
</rendering>
</sim>
</PropertyList>
You cant have both set to ture, or both as false, and you cant miss out one or the other.