Alex, yes I agree with your points. I think for me at least the point of this petition is responding to the forced, non-democratic way in which we were 'told'. Effectively a middle finger up to 'the man'.
So for me, how will this play out? I run an Ubuntu phone. No way of operating a mainstream app.
They suggest alternative methods for elderly or homeless people, which in my mind is quite a discriminatory and presumptuous statement, tarring several groups with the same brush, and completely ignoring the people like me who are interested in keeping as private as possible regarding data privacy. Blindly assuming that if you are neither elderly, nor homelss you will have an Apple or Android phone, and it will be up to date enough to run thir new app. I sit outside of this presumed half baked logic, as do many others.
Basically, as a person who has willingly paid tax since I started working at the age of 17, never put a foot out of line, I'm now faced with a choice to either have my deep rooted rights to privacy comprimised, or will be unable to work legally, only able to work cash in hand, and not pay any more tax.
I wonder if getting a job based from anothr country would help to avoid this nonsesne, or maybe becoming a sole trader and contracting?
I see Alex's points, however, there is one further point to consider. How many times have we heard about the government employee leaving a laptop on a train/bus... Or the data breaches... Why place yourself on yet another database that could be susceptible to attack? In my mind its damage limitation by reducing the number of entities that could potentially leak your data, and minimising the data they hold. And when has a government ever actually implemented aything like this successfully without mishaps...? Sorry, but I find it hard to put my trust into them. Just look at the recent Horizon Post Office scandal!!
Presenlty the distriuted/individual nature of databases you described is potentially safer, as not all eggs are in one basket. You'd have to hack the DVLA, the Passport agency, tax office, department for pensions, local council, our Church's safe, mobile phone companies, banks, credit card companies, GP surgery, NHS hospitals, in order to gather all those records into one handy place.
It sucks being told to go againt a deep belief. I'm not religious, but i can see how religious people feel when people cut into their beliefs.